The guys at NMA are twats. Most of their members have a permanent vendetta against any Bethesda-made Fallout.
I thought I'd be done with this a few years ago, but I'll say it again: Anyone who thinks Fallout could have stayed a top-down, turn-based rpg and still been good or successful is a moron with glued-on nostalgia goggles. Learn trends, learn the industry. There's a reason a Wasteland sequel took 26 years and was purely crowdfunded.